If you’ve never shopped on Etsy, it’s time to change that! It’s my favorite place to find home decor, presents for friends and family, art, and of course, jewelry. I’ve purchased countless pieces of jewelry on Etsy and have been so happy with every item, which is why I decided to write this article about the best Etsy jewelry shops.
The cool thing about Etsy is you can find just about any style of jewelry you want. Etsy also has jewelry pieces across varying price points, which is why this article is a round-up of the best Etsy jewelry shops, no matter your budget. I pulled pieces under $50, $100, and $200. Keep reading to discover some of your soon-to-be favorite jewelry shops.
Note from Hailey: We all need a little makeover sometimes. This article was originally published in 2021 and has been updated and revamped for accuracy and consistency.
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. Thank you for supporting my site and read more about my disclosure policies here.
Is Etsy A Good Place To Buy Jewelry?
Etsy is one of the best places to buy jewelry because of the sheer abundance of shops and product options. Whether you’re looking to spice up your earring collection or you’re looking for the perfect everyday gold necklace, Etsy is the best place to buy jewelry.
The best reason to buy jewelry on Etsy is that you are supporting small businesses when doing so which is a true win.
The Best Etsy Jewelry Shops
Let’s dive into the best jewelry Etsy shops, starting with my favorite stores that offer jewelry under $50.
Quick disclaimer, these shops were placed in each bucket if a majority of their products are under the specified price points. There may be some outliers within the shops. Let’s get into it!
Best Etsy Jewelry Shops Under $50
Babeina specializes in statement, trendy, and minimalist jewelry pieces. This is one of the best Etsy shops simply due to the number of pieces you can shop, with a majority of products under $50! Handcrafted in Sugarland, Texas, Babeina uses high-quality gold-filled and plated products. Their products are also anti-tarnish, hypoallergenic, and waterproof.
This Etsy jewelry shop is fairly young (founded in 2020) but has a 5-star rating with over 250K sales! That’s how you know Babeina is a trusted source for affordable jewelry pieces. Some of my favorites are this butterfly necklace and croissant hoops.
Located in Northern California, Wild Moonstone offers affordable jewelry that is made to last. The founder, Denise, takes pride in creating high-quality minimalist jewelry that doesn’t break the bank. The shop’s motivation is to create products that are transitional between a number of seasons and styles, helping eliminate waste within the jewelry industry.
All jewelry from Wild Moonstone is hand-crafted. While this shop does offer pricier items, they have a wide selection of pieces under $50 including gold tiny dot earrings, stacking gold rings, and a gold circle necklace. This shop creates hypoallergenic jewelry pieces and also offers a one-year warranty. If you’re a minimalist lover, Wild Moonstone is perfect for you.
Elevado is a woman-owned and operated jewelry shop based in Toronto. The shop specializes in ear jewelry with high-quality solid 925 sterling silver and all hypoallergenic materials. Elevado is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops because they offer jewelry styles in numerous colors and you can mix & match nearly all of the styles they offer.
This shop offers jewelry for any type of ear piercing you have whether it’s lobe or cartilage. If you want dainty ear jewelry with bold twists, Elevado is a great choice for you. A few of their best pieces include their huggie hoop earrings, climber stud earrings, and dainty everyday ear stack set which features 3 styles in a set.
NOLIAjewelry is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops due to its expertise in marrying modern and elegant minimalism. Established in 2014, this jewelry shop is handmade and most items are customizable if you want to add some personalization to your jewelry.
This shop uses durable and long-lasting materials to create items that won’t turn green or fade if you happen to shower or swim with them on. All of their raw metals are sourced within the USA and gemstone pieces have the option to be made from a lab-created stone or a natural stone. NOLIAjewelry also offers most products in gold, rose gold, or silver depending on your preference. Some of my favorite pieces include these tiny dot hoops, pearl necklace, and sequin chain bracelet.
Darling Jewelry Studio offers dainty, luxe jewelry with the option for a personalized touch. They offer a number of minimalist products that can be personalized with your initials which is why they landed on this list of the best Etsy jewelry shops.
This family-run store ethically crafts all items in Miami. They offer top-quality 14k solid gold, 925 sterling silver, 14k rose gold-filled, and many more finishes. Check out their gold hoop earrings to dress up your ears, as well as their dainty bracelet and tiny letter necklace for a personalized feel.
MUSEENDLESS is one of the best Etsy shops because of its unique jewelry styles. If you’re looking for affordable statement pieces that will have people asking “where did you get that?” then this is the perfect shop for you.
If you’re a lover of subtle color, MUSEENDLESS offers numerous pieces that will add a hint of color to your look whether that’s a blush pink or jade green. Check out this jade pendant charm necklace or hoop earrings to see exactly what I mean.
Best Etsy Jewelry Shops Under $100
GLDN carefully curates all of its stunning hand-crafted jewelry directly in their Pacific Northwest studio in Washington. A majority of their offerings fall under the $100 price range and consist of various products from initial necklaces, stacking rings, stud earrings, and dainty bracelets. GLDN also offers custom products for a more personalized touch. All of their products are high-quality 14K gold filled, sterling silver, or rose gold filled.
This is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops due to the emphasis they place on layering, specifically when it comes to necklaces. Layering is a great way to dress up, or down, your look. Take this personalized layered initial necklace (set of 2). Also, check out this personalized stacking ring (perfect for a gift) and this pearl bracelet.
8. Half Full LA
Half Full LA is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops for beaded and gemstone jewelry. All products are made in Los Angeles with love. If you’re looking for subtle statement pieces, specifically bracelets, this is the shop for you. Take The Native Clay Bracelet which is a Japanese glass seed bead bracelet with Japanese glass seed beads. This bracelet is a must-have with its beige and rust-colored beads.
This shop offers the option for you to upgrade most gold-filled jewelry to 14K gold or higher (although do note this will raise the price). Some of my favorite gold pieces consist of The May Bracelet made of genuine emerald and The Tessa Necklace which is a paperclip chain. I also love the names Half Full LA assigns to their items, which adds a special touch.
Sarah Elise Jewelry is unique because they work with hand-cut gemstones and ethically sourced diamonds. That’s not the only amazing thing about this Etsy jewelry shop as their jewelry expertise goes back 3 generations of techniques and passion for making jewelry. This shop takes pride in crafting fine jewelry perfect for any style.
At the time of this post, Sarah Elise Jewelry offers over 800 jewelry pieces and while many of them are over $100, there are many solid pieces of jewelry under that $100 price point. Check out two of their most eye-catching pieces, the solid gold paperclip chain ring, and the solid gold dainty chain bracelet.
10. Bijou Limon
If you’re a romantic at heart, Bijou Limon is the perfect shop for you. The designer, Kristina, creates jewelry collections that have a romantic French twist alongside current trends. If I had to choose any jewelry shop on this list to stock up on romantic, timeless statement pieces, it would be Bijou Limon.
This Etsy jewelry shop will transport you to France with their stunning heart-shaped pieces and other unique shapes you won’t find elsewhere. Whether you’re looking for necklaces, rings, earrings, or bracelets, Bijou Limon will have something for you. Check out this gorgeous heart locket ring that gives Marie Antoinette vibes or these pink heart earrings perfect for those who love pink.
11. Myrrh Jewelry
Myrrh Jewelry is a Los Angeles-based jewelry shop. They hand-make artisan jewelry and specialize in a number of styles including geometric jewelry, dainty necklaces, 14k gold earrings, stacking bracelets, and much much more.
If you’re looking for dainty pieces, I highly recommend you check out this Etsy shops’ earrings. They have a number of 14 karat gold earrings, including this double chain earring and this ear cuff. Beyond this, be sure to check out this initial bracelet or initial gold hoops for a personal touch.
If you’re on the hunt for bridal jewelry, Wander and Lust Jewelry is the perfect Etsy shop for you. Many products are under $100 so you don’t have to break the bank investing in your bridal jewelry. This shop offers a number of dainty necklaces, timeless bracelets, glam earrings, and gemstone rings.
Wander and Lust Jewelry sells a number of matching earrings and necklace for you to effortlessly match your jewelry. If you’re looking for your “Something Blue” check out these blue earrings made with freshwater pearls and Montana blue glass. If you’re looking for a matching pearl necklace, take a look at this pearl drop necklace.
Best Etsy Jewelry Shops Under $200
Brooke Michele Designs is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops for the modern and active woman. These pieces of jewelry are fine and dainty, perfect for someone looking to add a subtle hint of personality to their look. All of Brooke Michele Designs are made using 14K solid gold with genuine gemstones and natural diamonds.
The amazing thing about this Etsy shop is that it is run by a mother-daughter duo in Boston! You can really feel the passion in these jewelry pieces. Some of my favorites include their citrine charm bracelet, 14K gold engraved charm necklace, and these 14k solid gold hoop earrings.
14. Atelier Elise
Calling all brides-to-be! Atelier Elise is one of the best Etsy jewelry shops for your special day and beyond. Here you will find feminine, radiant pieces that are sure to bring your entire look together on your big day.
Atelier Elise is a great place to shop for your wedding jewelry as you won’t break the bank with most pieces being under $200. Alongside jewelry, Atelier Elise sells beautiful hair accessories that would top off your perfect wedding look. Check out this pearl and floral hair comb, as well as this celestial pearl cluster earrings and dainty pearl layered necklace.
JKISSLIFEJEWELRY is your one-stop shop for all things elegant. This Etsy jewelry shop sells a number of pieces with a primary focus on solid gold earrings. Alongside this, they sell solid gold rings, necklaces, and bracelets.
This New Jersey jewelry shop sells products across a number of prices but they landed under the $200 and below spot because of their earrings which include this beautiful pair of 9K solid gold angel wing drop earrings and these 14K solid gold CZ pave studs. If you want high-quality earrings with unique designs and brilliant diamonds, this is the best Etsy jewelry shop for you.
Cacee&B creates classic gold jewelry pieces in Toronto, Canada. If timeless designs are your thing, then this is the perfect Etsy shop for you as these pieces will never go out of style. Timeless, classic, and perfect for any look.
The high-quality craftsmanship of these pieces is clear to see. Many styles also come in silver, alongside 14K gold. All pieces are also safe for sensitive skin. For the perfect timeless piece, check out the freshwater pearl necklace, the 14K solid gold flat huggie hoops, and the 10K zodiac necklace.
17. Luxue Jewelry
Luxue Jewelry creates high-quality solid 925 sterling silver and 14k yellow gold jewelry right in Los Angeles. While this shop offers a number of rings, necklaces, and bracelets, their earrings are sure to stun. Of their earring selection, Luxue Jewelry offers many huggies, studs, and hoops.
This shop offers buy 3 get 1 free which is perfect for anyone shopping for holiday gifts. Of these beautiful pieces, my favorite happen to be the medium thick 14K gold hoops, 14K gold mirror chain necklace, and the mini diamond huggies.
18. Ke Aloha Jewelry
Ke Aloha Jewelry was founded in Hawaii after jewelry making started as a creative outlet for Lisa, who was a stay-at-home mom. Ke Aloha Jewelry pieces remind me of the ocean, which always brings me to a happy place, and why they landed on this list of the best Etsy jewelry shops.
This shop offers more than 300 styles to choose from. In my opinion, best of the best consists of the floating tahitian pearl necklace set and statement tanzanite ring. If you’re looking for dreamy, refreshing styles, Ke Aloha is for you.
I hope this article was helpful for you to find the best Etsy jewelry shops to fulfill all of your jewelry needs! Thank you for supporting the small businesses on Etsy with any of your purchases. Trust me, it goes a long way.
With love or whatever,