If you’ve never shopped on Etsy, you’re really missing out. It’s my favorite place to find home decor, presents for friends and family, art, and of course, jewelry. I’ve purchased countless pieces of jewelry on Etsy and have been so happy with every item, which is why I decided to write this article about the best Etsy jewelry shops.
The cool thing about Etsy is you can find just about any jewelry you want. They also have pieces across varying price points, which is why this article is a round-up of the best Etsy jewelry shops, no matter your budget. I pulled pieces under $50, $100, and $200. Keep reading to discover some of your soon-to-be favorite jewelry shops.
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. Thank you for supporting my site and read more about my disclosure policies here.
Is Etsy A Good Place To Buy Jewelry?
Etsy is one of the best places to buy jewelry. There are so many shops and products to browse through, so the opportunities are truly endless. Plus, not only can you find incredibly unique and beautiful jewelry, but you’re also supporting small businesses when doing so. Nothing gets better than that!
The Best Etsy Jewelry Shops
Let’s dive into the best jewelry Etsy shops, starting with my favorite stores that offer jewelry under $50. Quick disclaimer, the price points below are for the specific products I mention. These shops may offer products that are over or under the specified amount, so keep that in mind!
Under $50
Babeina
Babeina is an Etsy jewelry shop that handcrafts all of its jewelry using high-quality gold-filled and plated products. They have the cutest, trendy pieces including these butterfly earrings and this smiley face necklace.
One of my favorite things about Babeina is that they offer a variety of chains to choose from with your necklaces. If you’re looking for cute minimalistic jewelry, Babeina is perfect for you.
Shop My Favorite Under $50 Pieces
Wild Moonstone
Wild Moonstone creates affordable jewelry that is made to last. They sell various jewelry pieces including bracelets and necklaces, but I’m an especially huge fan of their earrings.
Wild Moonstone has the most affordable studs that are handcrafted and accessible to anyone who loves high-quality everyday jewelry.
Shop My Favorite Under $50 Pieces
Elevado
I purchased one of my favorite matching hoop earring sets from Elevado. This jewelry shop is women-owned and takes pride in dressing its customer’s ears with the cutest jewelry pieces. All of their jewelry is made with high-quality solid 925 sterling silver and hypoallergenic materials.
If you’re looking to decorate your ears with more than your typical, basic jewelry, you need to check out this amazing Etsy jewelry shop. Plus, they ship in plastic-free packaging. Doesn’t get much better than that!
Shop My Favorite Under $50 Pieces
Minimalist Magnolia
Minimalist Magnolia is the perfect combination of modern and elegant minimalist jewelry. Every jewelry piece is handmade and made to order. Plus, a ton of their items are customizable, which is one of my favorite things about Etsy.
I’m obsessed with all of their gold pieces, especially anything with pearls. Fun fact, they even have a storefront in California!
Shop My Favorite Under $50 Pieces
Darling Jewelry Studio
Darling Jewelry Studio offers dainty, luxe personalized jewelry that is made with love and ethically produced. They offer top-quality 14k solid gold, 925 sterling silver, 14k rose gold-filled, and many more finishes.
Their bracelets are definitely some of their best pieces. They make such a subtle statement on your wrist so they are 100% a must-have (I think I need to grab one for my jewelry collection).
Shop My Favorite Under $50 Pieces
Under $100
GLDN
GLDN designs and creates all of its beautiful hand-crafted jewelry in its Pacific Northwest studio in Washington. All of their jewelry is created in high-quality 14k gold-filled, sterling silver, and rose gold-filled finishes.
My favorite pieces they offer are their layered necklaces, which are perfect for those who love a layered look.
Shop My Favorite Under $100 Pieces
Half Full LA
Half Full LA sells the most gorgeous handmade, gold-filled pieces along with 14k beaded and gemstone jewelry. You can definitely feel the love that goes into making these beautiful pieces. They also offer you the option to upgrade any gold-filled jewelry to 14k gold or higher, and can also be changed to various finishes including silver and rose gold.
If you’re looking for custom jewelry, Half Full LA is a great place to look. Some of their best pieces are their bracelets, which everyone needs at least one of in their jewelry collection!
Shop My Favorite Under $100 Pieces
Sarah Elise Jewelry
Sarah Elise Jewelry is one of the coolest Etsy jewelry shops because they handcraft each piece of jewelry with 3 generations of techniques and passion. They are clearly experts within the jewelry field and it’s clear to see that through their high-quality hand-cut gemstones and ethically sourced full-cut diamonds.
They also work with 14k solid gold (can you guys tell I love gold yet?). This amazing shop also offers the option to make pretty much any item for you. So if you don’t see something you want, then message the shop and they will create it for you.
Shop My Favorite Under $100 Pieces
Atelier Elise
If you’re a soon-to-be bridge, Atelier Elise is a great place to shop for affordable jewelry under $100. But hey, even if you’re not going to be a bride, they still have some amazingly cute pieces for you!
Atelier Elise sells the most beautiful dainty jewelry pieces, along with some hair accessories which I’m obsessed with. If you’re looking for delicate, tasteful jewelry then this is the best Etsy jewelry shop for you.
Shop My Favorite Under $100 Pieces
Myrrh Jewelry
Myrrh Jewelry sells hand-made artisan jewelry from LA. They specialize in a variety of styles including geometric jewelry, dainty necklaces, 14k gold earrings, stacking bracelets, and much much more.
Personally, I’m a huge fan of their stud earrings because they come in so many shapes and designs that you won’t find anywhere else. Seriously, don’t sleep on Myrrh jewelry!
Shop My Favorite Under $100 Pieces
Under $200
Brooke Michele Designs
Brooke Michele Designs sells personalized fine-crafted jewelry. The cool thing about this Etsy shop is that it is run by a mother-daughter duo! All of their pieces are handmade in Boston and use 14k solid gold, high-quality cut diamonds, and genuine gemstones.
You can feel the passion they put into their jewelry. I’m a huge fan of their gemstone necklaces which are so gorgeous, especially birthstone necklaces (mine is a garnet!).
Shop My Favorite Under $200 Pieces
Design Gold Jewelry
Design Gold Jewelry is probably one of my favorite Etsy jewelry shops mentioned in this article. Their dainty and delicate pieces are perfect for anyone looking to add subtle, classic accessories to their style.
Some of my favorite pieces are their necklaces with cute pendants on them. I especially love their gold pearl necklace, check it out below!
Shop My Favorite Under $200 Pieces
Cacee&B
Cacee&B is created in Toronto, Canada, and they sell the most stunning gold jewelry out there. This is jewelry that will last you a lifetime thanks to the high-quality craftsmanship and general timelessness of the designs.
I’m in love with their “paperclip” styles made for necklaces and bracelets. They also sell the cutest anklets, which definitely need to be more trendy than they are!
Shop My Favorite Under $200 Pieces
Luxue Jewelry
Luxue Jewelry creates high-quality solid 925 sterling silver and 14k yellow gold jewelry right in their workshop. Their earrings are a particular fan favorite as they are subtle yet statement-making pieces.
Plus, the shop offers buy 3 get 1 free if you’re shopping for multiple pieces or multiple people! I’m also a huge fan of their chain designs, especially the gold chain link ring which you can see below.
Shop My Favorite Under $200 Pieces
Ke Aloha Jewelry
Last, but certainly not least we have Ke Aloha Jewelry. This is an incredibly special Etsy jewelry shop because they are based in Hawaii! Ke Aloha Jewelry was started by a stay-at-home mom who was able to turn her dream into a full-time job.
The jewelry offered here is reflective of the beauty Hawaii offers, with countless designs featuring shimmery jewels and unique styles.
Shop My Favorite Under $200 Pieces
Let’s Wrap It Up
That’s all, folks! I hope this article was helpful for you to find the best Etsy jewelry shops to fulfill all of your jewelry needs! Thank you for supporting the small businesses on Etsy with any of your purchases. Trust me, it goes a long way.
Don’t forget to check out this article on 10 Sustainable Jewelry Brands if you need even more inspo or options to choose from!
With love or whatever,
Hailey
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.